Why JobKeeper’s end won’t derail the recovery

Besa Deda
and
Matthew Bunny
06:33pm March 18 2021

Tourism destinations like Dreamworld on the Gold Coast have been among the most impacted businesses from COVID-19 restrictions. (Getty)

JobKeeper has provided extraordinary support to individuals and businesses since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. Unsurprisingly, with the conclusion of the program fast approaching at the end of March, there’s questions around how the economy can cope, even with the federal government’s fresh $1.2 billion package for the tourism and aviation sectors.  

First off, the labour market is clearly recovering. 

That’s not to say that everything is even. Some industries – arts, recreation, accommodation and food services – will continue to face significant challenges. But the end of JobKeeper will only temporarily slow the recovery and the broader “fiscal cliff” we once feared has actually been averted. 

There are good reasons why.

The support provided by JobKeeper has already stepped down significantly. At its peak in 2020, around 3.6 million workers were on JobKeeper. By the end of January, that number had shrunk to 960,000. When JobKeeper ends in a few weeks, the figure should be lower again.

Add to this the strengthening economic recovery and it’s safe to say we are heading towards a “financial slope”, rather than a “financial cliff”. 

The economy grew at a blistering pace of 3.1 per cent in the December quarter, following strong growth in the September quarter. This growth has led us to revise up our economic growth forecast for 2021 to 4.5 per cent. Low interest rates, infrastructure spending, the upturn in the housing market, the vaccine roll-out and solid spending by consumers are supporting the economy. 

Economic growth of 4.5 per cent is well above “trend” growth levels and will see the creation of more jobs, business investment and housing construction.

It’s worth noting that the jobs market has already almost fully recovered all of the jobs lost during March to May 2020 – 99.8 per cent to be precise! 

Moreover, the unemployment rate has declined from 7.5 per cent in July 2020 to an 11-month low of 5.8 per cent in February 2021. While that remains 0.8 percentage points higher than its low in February 2020, it’s still far better than feared in the depths of the crisis a year ago. 
 

Encouragingly, leading indicators of labour market demand, such as job advertisements and vacancies, point to further jobs growth over the coming months. 

If we look across the country at the differences in labour markets and within industries, there is, however, a more nuanced cliff-to-slope story.

New South Wales and Victoria had the largest take up of JobKeeper, being the states hardest hit by mobility restrictions and international border closures. At the end of 2020, Victoria had around one in five workers on JobKeeper and NSW had around one in ten. 

Across industries, some have also received more support from JobKeeper than others. 

In the December quarter, the construction and professional services sectors accounted for the largest dollar value of JobKeeper payments. These industries are huge employers. Sole traders and other small businesses dominate business in Australia and so made up a large share of the organisations on JobKeeper.
 

For a better measure of the industries relying on JobKeeper we’ve taken a look at support payments as a share of total wages paid. According to this metric, arts and recreation was the worst hit sector in the December quarter. JobKeeper payments were the highest in this industry as a share of wages, sitting at 25 per cent. The second most reliant industry was the accommodation and food services sector, JobKeeper payments accounting for 16.6 per cent of wages paid. 

The hospitality industry has suffered immensely from restrictions, and with international borders due to remain closed until late 2021, the lack of foreign tourists will continue to weigh on this sector for some time. 

It’s worth noting that the number of people employed working zero hours for economic reasons was around 127,000 in February 2021, well under the peak of around 770,000 in April 2020. This number refers to people who were employed but stood down or where there was insufficient work available. This cohort is likely to be receiving the JobKeeper payment and are the most vulnerable to unemployment when the program ends. 

Inevitably, there will be job losses in coming months and a temporary slowing in the recovery in the labour market. Of course, it is difficult to know precisely how many people will lose their jobs. 

The government has been at pains to underscore that it will be a small share of recipients and based on strength of the recovery to date, we agree. 

We estimate 60,000 – 140,000 people could be stood down at the end of JobKeeper. Some people on JobKeeper are employed and will remain employed, some people will find a job quickly in the recovering jobs market and some people may drop out of the labour force for a time. 

Job losses are likely to be concentrated in industries exposed to travel restrictions and ongoing social-distancing regulations – accommodation and food, arts and recreation, travel agencies and related services and air transport. These industries have more employees working zero or low hours. 

However, the government’s recent support package for the travel, tourism and aviation sectors should help ease some of the pain when JobKeeper ends.

We’re predicting a baseline scenario where the unemployment rate remains near the current level until the end of June before it resumes declining to end the year at a lower unemployment rate – a relatively quick improvement compared to prior recessions.

JobKeeper has lived up to its name.

And thankfully, the economy is bouncing back faster than expected alongside the conclusion of the program, which always had to come at some point.


The information in this article is general information only, it does not constitute any recommendation or advice; it has been prepared without taking into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs and you should consider its appropriateness with regard to these factors before acting on it. Any taxation position described is a general statement and should only be used as a guide. It does not constitute tax advice and is based on current tax laws and our interpretation. Your individual situation may differ and you should seek independent professional tax advice. You should also consider obtaining personalised advice from a professional financial adviser before making any financial decisions in relation to the matters discussed.
 

Besa Deda

Besa is the Chief Economist of Westpac’s Business Bank. She is also the Chief Economist of St.George Bank, Bank of Melbourne, BankSA and BT, which are other businesses within the Westpac Group. Besa has been with the group since 2009 and is a key spokesperson on the economy and financial markets. She manages a team of economists, regularly presents to clients and appears in the media. Besa is also Chair of the Australian Business Economists organisation and a member of ANU’s Centre for Applied Macroeconomic Analysis RBA Shadow Board. Besa was appointed the Chief Economist of St.George Bank in 2008, a role which saw her become the first female Chief Economist of a bank in Australia. Prior to this, she worked at the CBA and Colonial. She has previously lectured for the Kaplan Business School and written a regular property column for the Weekend Australian.

Matthew Bunny

Matthew joined Westpac in early 2021. He is an Economist in several businesses, including Westpac Business Bank, St.George Bank, BankSA, Bank of Melbourne and BT. Previously, Matthew spent five years at the Reserve Bank of Australia where he worked in various roles spanning the Australian consumer sector and international financial markets. Matthew holds a Bachelor of Commerce (Economics) with First Class Honours from the University of Western Australia.

Don't miss

Related articles

Consumers are feeling more confident, with caveats

By Matthew Hassan
Senior Economist, Westpac

Trump’s bark may be worse than his bite on trade

By James Thornhill
Editor, Westpac Wire

Millennials to lead the charge on Black Friday spending

By James Thornhill and Marina Gainulina

Browse topics